Treasury Changes to Evaluating Capital Projects

20 February 2026

New Green Book published

The Green Book, published by HM Treasury in February (See link at bottom of the post), updates guidance for capital spending decisions across the UK. The new approach aims to ensure fairer investment in all regions, including urban, rural, and coastal areas beyond London and the South East.

It moves away from relying solely on benefit-cost ratios, requiring consideration of broader impacts when comparing projects. Benefit-cost ratios have tended to favour London and the Southeast as the due to the larger and more vibrant economy cases were easier to make.

 This change supports more balanced public investment, such as new transport links, town centre regeneration, housing, and infrastructure, and aligns with the Government’s goal to promote nationwide growth. As the standard for appraising and evaluating public spending, the Green Book shapes how resources are allocated and which projects move forward.

A review in 2025 revealed that the previous Green Book was overly lengthy and complicated, the updated edition is now clearer, easier to use, and over 40% shorter than before.  In addition an independent review of the social discount rate is underway, which could make long-term sustainable/green projects more financially attractive.

Claimed Benefits

  • Benefit to cost ratio is no longer the Pass/ Fail test. This allows projects in more deprived regions to stand a chance even if their immediate economic return looks lower than major cities’ equivalent.
  • Simplification: The document is 40% shorter and in easily accessible language.
  • Strategic Over Individual: It moves away from appraising ‘isolated projects’ and toward ‘strategic programmes’.
  • Long-term thinking is emphasised – encourages considering systemic impact, risks, and lasting benefits.
  • Evaluation is integrated from the start – capturing lessons as projects progress creates a cycle of continuous improvement, helping investments achieve more.
  • Ability to bundle projects (e.g., housing, transport and energy) into a single Place-Based Business Case, making integrated masterplans easier to fund.
  • Recognition of long-term change” means projects that create new markets (rather than just serving existing ones) will receive higher scores.
  • Emphasis on proportionality which would mean more simplified process for smaller projects.

The Green Book also tightens up on certain aspects related to major schemes including, tighter rules on cost-overruns and risk assessment mean developers must provide more robust data on delivery timelines and cost certainty.

Chancellor of the Exchequer Rachel Reeves said:

The new Green Book still recognises the importance of robust evidence and analysis, and metrics like benefit-cost ratios – but is clear these must not be used as a crude pass/fail test. Ministers will now see a more rounded assessment of a proposal’s impacts, rather than being guided by one headline number.

The new guidance has been developed hand-in-hand with devolved administrations, mayoral combined authorities and local councils, and supports the aim of this government to change the way the state makes decisions: promoting decision making that supports higher, more productive and more balanced growth across the whole of the United Kingdom.

Why does this matter?

For those who are currently bidding for or planning a project involving public land or funding – there is a need to rethink the pitch. It is not all about the monetisable benefits associated with the project, the strategic link to Local Plans and Social Value interventions becomes increasingly important.

As noted above getting schemes approved in the Southeast may get more difficult.  However, well-constructed schemes within the context of a Spatial Development Strategy may be easier to fund e.g. Couple Town Centre Development with a Flood Alleviation Scheme.

Downloads

Share this article

Related Articles

Help us make Guildford better

We want our town to be vibrant, attractive and liveable. We support development that brings a sense of place and enhances the best aspects of our town. If such aims can be embraced, we believe Guildford has the chance to lead the way in enabling sensitive and sustainable development.

Pressures for development are increasing. Planning rules are being eased. The Society’s commitment to standing up for Guildford is needed more than ever.

Support Us

Getting involved allows the society to continue its work.   We welcome new members, from every age and background.  Membership provides an opportunity for you to contribute to the continued health of the town and surrounding area, and to meet other people who care about Guildford.